11 Perfect Oregano Substitutes for Any Recipe

Oregano is a staple herb in many kitchens around the world, known for its robust and earthy flavor. It’s commonly used in Italian, Mediterranean, and Mexican cuisines, adding a distinctive taste to pizzas, pasta sauces, salads, soups, and more. But what if you’re cooking and realize you’ve run out of oregano? Or perhaps you’re cooking for someone who dislikes its strong flavor? Don’t worry—there are plenty of oregano substitutes that can save your dish without compromising flavor!

In this guide, we’ll explore the best substitutes for dried oregano, what makes each one unique, and how to use them in your cooking. We’ll also cover alternatives to Mexican oregano, a variety with a slightly different flavor profile, and other great options to keep your dishes flavorful and aromatic.

What is Oregano?

Oregano, often called the “pizza herb,” is part of the mint family and is known for its warm, pungent, and slightly bitter flavor with peppery and earthy undertones. Commonly available in two main varieties —Mediterranean oregano and Mexican oregano — this perennial herb plays a significant role in various cuisines including Italian, Greek, and Mexican cuisines.

Mediterranean Oregano

This is the variety typically used in Italian and Mediterranean dishes, with a minty and slightly sweet taste.

Mexican Oregano

This type has citrusy and earthy notes, making it a perfect fit for Mexican and Southwestern recipes.

Why You Might Need an Oregano Substitute

Oregano, a versatile herb with a distinctive flavor, is a staple in many kitchens. However, there are instances when you might find yourself without this aromatic herb. Here are some common reasons why you might need an oregano substitute:

Out-of-Stock

• You’ve run out of oregano: Yep, the most common reason! It happens to everyone—you start cooking and realize you’ve run out of oregano. Instead of halting your recipe, knowing substitutes like thyme, basil, or marjoram can save your dish.
• Grocery Store Shortages: Sometimes, your local grocery store might be temporarily out of stock of fresh or dried oregano.
• Seasonal Availability: If you prefer fresh oregano over dried oregano leaves, the fresh one may not be readily available during certain seasons.

Different Flavor Profiles

Some recipes might need a different flavor profile that complements the dish better. For instance, Mexican oregano has a citrusy, slightly earthy taste, which may not work in all recipes, requiring a subtler substitute like parsley or marjoram.

Allergies or Sensitivities

In rare cases, people may have an allergy or sensitivity to oregano. Finding alternatives such as thyme or basil can keep the dish safe and enjoyable for everyone.

Dietary Preferences or Restrictions

Some individuals avoid certain herbs due to personal dietary preferences or cultural cuisine differences. Oregano has a strong, unique taste, and some people may find it too overpowering. A substitute that aligns with their needs can make meals inclusive.

Regional Availability

Oregano might not be easily available in some regions, making it necessary to use locally available herbs like thyme or mint.

Complementing a Specific Cuisine

While oregano is common in Mediterranean and Italian dishes, other cuisines might call for a different herb. For instance, in Indian dishes, coriander leaves could be a more suitable alternative.

Whatever the reason, by understanding these common scenarios, you can be prepared with suitable oregano substitutes to ensure your dish remains flavorful and true to its culinary roots!

Best Substitutes for Oregano

Here are some of the best alternatives to oregano that you can use in your recipes without compromising on the flavor.

1. Basil – A Mild Substitute for Oregano in Italian Dishes

Basil is one of the closest herbs to oregano, especially in Italian cuisine. With its slightly sweet, peppery flavor, basil can easily replace oregano in pasta sauces, pizzas, and even pesto.

• How to Use: Substitute in a 1:1 ratio for dried or fresh oregano.
• Best for: Italian and Mediterranean dishes like pasta sauces, marinades, and pizzas.

2. Thyme – A Versatile Substitute for Dried Oregano

Thyme is another fantastic substitute, offering a slightly earthy and minty flavor. It works well in soups, stews, and roasted dishes.

• How to Use: Use in a 1:1 ratio for dried oregano.
• Best for: Mediterranean and European recipes.

3. Marjoram – The Closest Flavor Match to Oregano

Marjoram is a close cousin to oregano and has a milder, more floral flavor. If you want something with a similar flavor profile, marjoram is an ideal choice.

• How to Use: Use marjoram in a 1:1 ratio for dried oregano.
• Best for: Italian and Mediterranean dishes.

4. Mexican Oregano Substitute – Cilantro or Epazote

If you need a substitute for Mexican oregano, cilantro and epazote are both good options. Mexican oregano has citrusy, earthy undertones, and these herbs provide similar flavors.

• How to Use: Use cilantro in a 1:1 ratio; use epazote sparingly as it has a stronger flavor.
• Best for: Mexican and Southwestern dishes like tacos, enchiladas, and salsa.

5. Parsley – A Mild Alternative for Garnishes

Though parsley doesn’t taste exactly like oregano, it can be a mild substitute, particularly for garnishes.

• How to Use: Use a bit more parsley than you would oregano to make up for the difference in flavor.
• Best for: Garnishes or as a mild flavor enhancer in soups and stews.

6. Italian Seasoning – A Blend That Includes Oregano

If you have Italian seasoning on hand, it can be a quick fix since it often contains oregano, along with basil, thyme, rosemary, and marjoram.

• How to Use: Use in a 1:1 ratio for dried oregano, but be cautious of the added flavors.
• Best for: Italian-inspired dishes, marinades, and sauces.

7. Rosemary – A Strong, Earthy Substitute

Rosemary is stronger and more pine-like than oregano, but it can add a pleasant earthiness to roasted dishes and stews.

• How to Use: Use sparingly, about half the amount called for oregano.
• Best for: Roasted meats, potatoes, and Mediterranean stews.

8. Sage – Earthy and Bold

Sage has a strong, earthy taste that’s somewhat similar to oregano but bolder. It’s best used in moderation.

• How to Use: Use half the amount of sage as you would oregano.
• Best for: Hearty soups, sauces, and stuffings.

9. Bay Leaves – For Soups and Stews

While bay leaves are quite different from oregano, they add an earthy flavor that complements many soups and stews.

• How to Use: Add one or two bay leaves to soups or stews as a replacement.
• Best for: Long-cooking dishes like stews, soups, and braises.

10. Dill – A Fresh, Slightly Tangy Option

If you’re looking for something a little different, dill offers a unique, tangy taste that can complement salads and lighter dishes.

• How to Use: Use sparingly, as dill is potent.
• Best for: Salads, seafood, and lighter dishes.

11. Mixed Herbs

A blend of herbs like thyme, rosemary, and sage can be a great substitute for oregano, offering a complex and flavorful combination.

• How to Use: Use the mixed herbs in equal amounts to oregano, in a 1:1 ratio.
• Best for: Stews, roasts, and casseroles.

Next, we discover some great substitutes for oregano for some common dishes, as well as a bunch of handy tips for using these substitutes. So, let’s get going!

A Pinch of Flavor: Best Oregano Substitutes for Pizza

If you’re out of oregano but still craving that classic pizza taste, basil is your best friend. With its mild, sweet, and slightly peppery flavor, basil perfectly mimics oregano’s Italian flair on pizzas. Other options like Italian seasoning or marjoram can also work well, adding the right depth to your pizza sauce and toppings.

Top Oregano Substitutes for Flavorful Chicken Dishes

For chicken recipes, thyme is an excellent oregano substitute. It adds a mild earthiness that complements the flavor of chicken beautifully. Rosemary also pairs well with chicken, especially in roasted or grilled dishes, adding a piney, aromatic twist to the meal.

Oregano Alternatives for Spaghetti Sauce

No oregano for your spaghetti sauce? Use basil or Italian seasoning instead. Both options add a familiar Italian aroma and taste to your sauce, keeping it rich and flavorful. Thyme and marjoram also work well to bring an earthy depth to the classic tomato-based sauce.

Herbs to Use as an Oregano Substitute in Lasagna

If you’re making lasagna without oregano, consider using basil or marjoram to fill in. These herbs add a similar Mediterranean warmth and richness to your lasagna layers. A sprinkle of thyme or Italian seasoning can also enhance the dish’s depth, keeping it savory and delicious.

Oregano Substitute Ideas for Tasty Meatballs

For meatballs, try substituting oregano with thyme or Italian seasoning. These herbs bring a mild and earthy flavor that complements the meat mixture without overpowering it. Basil is also a great option, adding a slightly sweet and peppery flavor to your Italian-style meatballs.

Bold Oregano Substitutes for Flavorful Chili

Mexican oregano is the best choice for chili, but if it’s unavailable, try using cumin and cilantro. These herbs bring earthy and citrusy notes that complement the spicy and robust flavors of chili. Another option is to mix thyme and paprika for a smoky, warm alternative.

Herbs to Substitute Oregano in Roasted Vegetables

For roasted vegetables, rosemary and thyme make great oregano substitutes. Both herbs add a piney and earthy flavor that pairs well with the caramelized, roasted goodness of vegetables. Use a sprinkle of Italian seasoning for an extra burst of flavor in your veggie mix.

Soup-er Substitutes: Oregano Alternatives for Soups

Thyme is a fantastic substitute for oregano in soups, adding a mild, earthy flavor that blends well with broths and vegetable bases. Marjoram is another great option, bringing a similar yet milder taste to soups without overpowering the dish. For heartier soups, consider using rosemary or a blend of dried herbs like Italian seasoning.

Tailor Your Flavor: Oregano Alternatives for DIY Homemade Seasoning Blends

If you’re making a homemade seasoning blend and don’t have oregano, try marjoram or basil. Both offer a Mediterranean touch that’s essential in blends like Italian seasoning. Thyme also works well, adding a subtle, earthy flavor that rounds out the mixture perfectly. Experiment with different ratios to achieve your desired flavor profile.

Tips for Using Oregano Substitutes

Beware of a few things while using other herbs in place of oregano, so that these substitutes don’t overpower the flavor base of the dish you’re making.

Taste as You Go

When using substitutes, taste your dish as you cook and adjust the seasoning accordingly.

Consider the Dish

The best substitute depends on the specific dish you’re preparing. For example, marjoram might be a better choice for Italian-inspired dishes, while thyme could work well with Mediterranean flavors.

Experiment and Have Fun

Don’t be afraid to experiment with different combinations of herbs and spices to find your perfect flavor profile.

Conclusion: Find the Right Substitute for Your Dish

While oregano is a fantastic herb, don’t let its absence deter you from creating delicious meals. Whether you’re cooking Italian, Mexican, or Mediterranean, there’s always a good substitute for oregano to enhance your dish. From basil and thyme to Mexican oregano alternatives like cilantro and epazote, these options ensure your recipes never lack flavor.

By understanding the flavor profiles of these substitutes, you can easily adapt your recipes and achieve similar results. So, next time you’re out of oregano, reach for one of these flavorful alternatives, and continue your culinary adventures!

FAQs

If you have any other questions or would like to share something, please feel free to comment below. I would love to hear from you.

And next time you’re in a pinch, refer to this guide and experiment with substitutes to keep your meals delicious and aromatic. Happy cooking!

You may also like: Creamy Chicken Mushroom Pasta Recipe

Latest Posts

Kitchen Backsplash: Ultimate Guide to Spruce Up Your Kitchen

6 Best Electric Potato Peeler Reviews (2024)

How High Should a Pot Filler be Above the Stove?